Marvel Cinematic Universe: The Good, The Bad and the Inconsistent

An Op-Ed by Mario Vargas

So as I listen to one of my favorite podcasts Newcomers, I end up doing the thing where I answer the questions that Lauren Lapkus and Nicole Byer ask their guests on their show. I am often running through my own history with the MCU, and since they ask the same question to every guest and I keep answering it, I decided to put my thoughts down on paper.

The MCU is pretty much the only thing that I go to the theater for, and I have for the past 7 years, basically since Age of Ultron. I have also been on Marvel Puzzle Quest and currently on day 2,678.

7e92d8 0eb698e798ef48b4836238548acb7060~mv2 Marvel Cinematic Universe: The Good, The Bad and the Inconsistent

Iron Man

Basically my history with the MCU: I saw Iron Man in theaters – thought it was pretty good. Next one I saw in theaters was Iron Man 2, and I thought it was fine. I didn’t keep up with it at all until I watched Winter Soldier, on a plane. I thought it was an awesome action movie, not just a Marvel superhero movie. It got me hooked. I finished the flight by watching Iron Man 3, then I went to see Ultron in theaters. It did lead to one of the few glaring flaws in the MCU’s idea of one long narrative, where Tony retires one movie but is immediately back the next.

It appears that I am not alone in some of the complaints and inconsistencies of quality both for the Marvel franchise as a whole and per movie. The most frequent negative comments I hear about the MCU are:

A) They are formulaic

B) They end on a CGI mushfest,

C) Nothing of consequence happens, and

D) They exist to make money/the integrity and quality now fall second to making money for the investors.

First, I’d like to share my tier designations consisting of both the MCU movies and the shows.

*Note: I don’t prefer origin stories.

S tier (Superior – The best of the best)

Captain America: Winter Soldier

Guardians of the Galaxy Vol 2

Avengers Infinity War

Doctor Strange and the Multiverse of Madness



Avengers Endgame

Guardians of the Galaxy

A tier (Excellent)

7e92d8 f7cb5d111fe04c1d89447f0afd99f14e~mv2 Marvel Cinematic Universe: The Good, The Bad and the Inconsistent

Thor Ragnarok

Shang Chi

Spiderman No Way Home

What if

Black Widow

Black Panther

Captain America Civil War

Spiderman Far from Home


7e92d8 45101b4f44464ac0b38614800f12c38c~mv2 Marvel Cinematic Universe: The Good, The Bad and the Inconsistent

B Tier (Great – I’d watch it again)

Spiderman Homecoming

Ant-Man and the Wasp

Iron Man


Captain America the First Avenger

Iron Man 3

Doctor Strange

7e92d8 03d3f33474834a659912d72ddb674628~mv2 Marvel Cinematic Universe: The Good, The Bad and the Inconsistent

C Tier (Good, not great)

Falcon and the Winter Soldier


Avengers Age of Ultron


7e92d8 2590111956284c5e9487ac43d57aab49~mv2 Marvel Cinematic Universe: The Good, The Bad and the Inconsistent

D Tier (Eh, one time is good enough)

Captain Marvel


Thor the Dark World


Iron Man 2


It was interesting to do this. I noticed that I enjoy the movies the more they are connected and the more the universe is expanded. I feel that they really hit a groove and became their own thing after Ultron. Early on they are a little too generic, following common action movie beats and not embracing the comic bookiness that they now do. Maybe, but it mostly works so I can forgive it.

I think they have done a great job of making these actions scenes work to incorporate great character specific points and use it to enhance the story. In a vacuum I think Shang Chi’s ending works, but I was taken aback at first that it had another run at each other fight. It’s getting muddy with the multiverse allowing characters to revive as variants, but this isn’t a big deal to me. I’m not mad Don Cheadle is still walking.

But one thing that no one can deny is that feeling you get when you walk into a theater on opening weekend, surrounded by fellow super fans ready to experience the movie the way it was made to be. I wouldn’t be surprised if subconsciously the movie theater experience had a positive effect on my opinion of the movie. Regardless of how the timeline, comic books, cinematic universe, series and other digestible media evolve over the coming years, today I am satisfied and always looking forward to what is next for Marvel.

Mario Vargas

Click here to see the list of the Marvel movies in chronological order.

Scroll to Top

%d bloggers like this: